State stories
40 accounts of one state in one election. Every sentence links to its source and quotes the words that support it.
2016
- Maine, 2016: the first split under the district system
In 2016 Maine split its electoral votes for the first time under its district system: Clinton won three, and Trump won one by carrying the Second Congressional District.
- Texas, 2016: two Republican electors vote for someone other than Trump
Donald Trump carried Texas in 2016, but 2 of its 38 electors voted for others: Chris Suprun for John Kasich and Bill Greene for Ron Paul.
- Washington, 2016: four electors break ranks, and a fine reaches the Supreme Court
Four of Washington's 2016 electors did not vote for Hillary Clinton; three were fined $1,000, and in Chiafalo v. Washington the Supreme Court ruled a state may enforce elector pledges.
2008
- Nebraska, 2008: the first split under the district system
In 2008 Nebraska split its electoral votes for the first time under its district system: McCain won four, and Obama won one by carrying the Second Congressional District.
2004
- Minnesota, 2004: an unsigned ballot for "John Ewards"
One of Minnesota's ten Kerry electors in 2004 voted for John Edwards for president; the ballots were unsigned, and who cast it was never established.
- Ohio, 2004: the deciding state and the objection in Congress
George W. Bush carried Ohio by 118,601 votes, and its 20 electoral votes gave him his majority; Congress rejected an objection to them, 74 to 1 and 267 to 31.
2000
- District of Columbia, 2000: a blank ballot in protest
A District of Columbia elector cast a blank ballot to protest the District's lack of representation in Congress, so only two of its three electoral votes were cast.
- Florida, 2000: 537 votes and a recount stopped by the Supreme Court
Official results gave George W. Bush a 537-vote lead in Florida, whose 25 electoral votes gave him a majority after the Supreme Court reversed a Florida recount order.
1988
- West Virginia, 1988: an elector reverses the Democratic ticket
A West Virginia elector for Michael Dukakis, Margaret Leach, voted for Lloyd Bentsen as president and Dukakis as vice president, switching the two halves of the Democratic ticket.
1976
- Washington, 1976: a Ford elector votes for Reagan
Washington voters backed Gerald Ford in 1976, but Republican elector Mike Padden of Spokane cast his presidential vote for Ronald Reagan instead.
1972
- Virginia, 1972: a Republican elector votes Libertarian, and a woman receives an electoral vote
Virginia elector Roger L. MacBride voted for Libertarians John Hospers and Tonie Nathan instead of Nixon and Agnew, making Nathan the first woman to receive an electoral vote.
1968
- Alabama, 1968: Wallace's electors run as the state's Democrats
George Wallace ran nationally in 1968 as the American Independent candidate, but in Alabama his electors were the state Democratic Party's nominees, while Humphrey's electors appeared in other columns.
- North Carolina, 1968: a Nixon elector votes for Wallace, and Congress counts it
North Carolina elector Lloyd W. Bailey voted for George Wallace instead of Richard Nixon; both houses of Congress rejected an objection, and the vote was counted as cast.
1960
- Alabama, 1960: a split slate, six votes for Byrd and a popular vote counted two ways
Alabama's Democratic electors were chosen one by one; five voted for Kennedy and six for Harry F. Byrd, so the state's popular vote has no single agreed split.
- Hawaii, 1960: a recount reversed the result and two slates of electors voted
Nixon was first certified the winner in Hawaii, but a court-ordered recount gave Kennedy a 115-vote lead, and Congress counted Hawaii's Democratic electors.
- Illinois, 1960: a margin under 9,000 votes and the fraud allegations
Kennedy carried Illinois by fewer than 9,000 votes; Republicans alleged fraud in Chicago, but a recount, the courts and the state board left the result unchanged.
- Mississippi, 1960: the unpledged slate that won
In 1960 Mississippi chose a slate of unpledged Democratic electors over both Kennedy's and Nixon's, and all eight voted for Senator Harry F. Byrd of Virginia.
- Texas, 1960: Johnson's home state and a 46,000-vote margin
Kennedy and his Texas running mate, Lyndon B. Johnson, carried Texas by about 46,000 votes; Republican suits challenging the result were thrown out by a federal judge.
1948
- Alabama, 1948: Truman left off the ballot, Thurmond listed as the Democrat
Alabama's 1948 Democratic electors pledged themselves to Strom Thurmond, who was listed on the ballot as the Democratic nominee, and President Truman was kept off the state's ballot.
- Ohio, 1948: 7,107 votes and the morning the forecasts fell
Truman carried Ohio in 1948 by 7,107 votes, and its 25 electoral votes, reported the morning after the election, gave him the 266 he needed to win.
- Tennessee, 1948: a Truman elector votes for Thurmond
Preston Parks, a Tennessee elector for Harry S. Truman, cast his 1948 electoral vote for Strom Thurmond of the States' Rights party, as he had vowed to do.
1916
- California, 1916: the state that reelected Wilson by a few thousand votes
Woodrow Wilson carried California by 3,773 votes in 1916, and its 13 electoral votes gave him a 277 to 254 victory over Charles Evans Hughes.
1912
- California, 1912: Roosevelt by 174 votes, and an 11-to-2 split
Theodore Roosevelt carried California in 1912 by 174 votes, but because voters chose electors directly, the state's 13 electoral votes split 11 for Roosevelt and 2 for Wilson.
1892
- Michigan, 1892: electors chosen by district, and a split vote
Under an 1891 law choosing electors by district, which the Supreme Court upheld in McPherson v. Blacker, Michigan split its 1892 electoral votes: 9 for Harrison, 5 for Cleveland.
1888
- Indiana, 1888: Harrison's home state and the "blocks of five" letter
Benjamin Harrison narrowly carried his home state of Indiana in 1888 amid an uproar over a Republican letter urging that paid "floaters" be organized into "blocks of five."
- New York, 1888: Cleveland loses his home state and the presidency
Grover Cleveland won about 90,000 more votes nationally than Benjamin Harrison in 1888 but narrowly lost his home state of New York, and with it the Electoral College.
1876
- Colorado, 1876: a new state whose legislature chose the electors
Admitted months before the 1876 election, Colorado had its legislature choose its three electors, who voted for Rutherford B. Hayes, the winner by 185 electoral votes to 184.
- Florida, 1876: rival electors and the Electoral Commission
Florida sent Congress rival sets of electoral votes in 1876; the Electoral Commission, with eight members concurring and seven not, counted all four for Rutherford B. Hayes.
- Louisiana, 1876: a returning board, two governors and eight disputed votes
Louisiana's returning board certified Hayes electors although unofficial returns showed Tilden ahead; the Electoral Commission, eight members to seven, counted all eight votes for Hayes.
- Oregon, 1876: the postmaster elector, Watts or Cronin
Oregon's governor certified E. A. Cronin in place of Hayes elector J. W. Watts, a postmaster; the Electoral Commission counted Watts's vote, giving Hayes all three Oregon votes.
- South Carolina, 1876: two governors, two legislatures and two sets of electors
South Carolina's presidential returns favored Hayes on their face, but rival electors and objections sent its 7 votes to the Electoral Commission, which counted them for Hayes.
1872
- Arkansas, 1872: electoral votes the two houses of Congress could not agree to count
Arkansas's 1872 electoral votes were never counted: the House voted to count them, the Senate voted not to, and under the joint rule that disagreement kept them out.
- Georgia, 1872: three electoral votes for a candidate who had died
Three Georgia electors voted for Horace Greeley after his death; the House voted not to count them, the Senate voted to count them, and they went uncounted.
- Louisiana, 1872: two rival returns, and none of them counted
Louisiana sent Congress rival sets of 1872 electoral returns, and both the House and the Senate voted that none of them should be counted.
1860
- Missouri, 1860: the one state Douglas carried
Missouri was the only state that gave Stephen A. Douglas all its electoral votes in 1860; within months its voters chose a convention that rejected secession.
- New Jersey, 1860: four electors for Lincoln, three for Douglas
New Jersey voters chose electors one by one in 1860; four Lincoln electors and three Douglas Democrats won, splitting the state's seven electoral votes.
- Virginia, 1860: Bell by 156 votes, then secession
John Bell carried Virginia by 156 votes in 1860; after Fort Sumter and Lincoln's call for troops, a state convention voted for secession and voters approved it in May 1861.
1824
- Kentucky, 1824: electors for Clay, a House vote for Adams
Kentucky's 14 electors voted for Henry Clay; when the House chose the president in 1825, Kentucky's vote went to John Quincy Adams despite the state legislature's instructions.
- New York, 1824: a legislature chooses 36 electors and splits them four ways
New York's legislature, not its voters, chose the state's 36 electors in 1824; they cast 26 votes for John Quincy Adams and the rest for three other candidates.
1800
- New York, 1800: the legislative election that chose the electors
New York's legislature chose its 1800 electors, so the spring legislative election, won by the Republicans, sent all 12 of the state's electoral votes to Jefferson.
Every other state’s result is in the table on its election page. How these stories are made